Contents
- What is covered, and the one thing that never is
- Replacement cost and actual cash value
- Recoverable depreciation and its deadline
- Policies that pay the roof by its age
- The cosmetic damage exclusion
- Like kind and quality
- After the claim: premium and renewal
- A plan for the policy you have
- Frequently asked questions
- Sources
The search behind this page is usually typed after a storm, by someone who has heard two contradictory things from neighbors: that the insurer bought one family a new roof, and that it offered another a check that would not cover the shingles. Both can be true on the same street. The difference is in the policy.
What is covered, and the one thing that never is
Regulators describe hail as a standard covered cause of loss. The Oklahoma Insurance Department's wording is that most standard homeowners insurance "will cover hail damage to your roof and other parts of your home", and that personal property damaged by hail and wind is covered too1. Some policies exclude wind or hail entirely, which is why the Texas Office of Public Insurance Counsel tells shoppers to ask. On the Texas coast the cover may have to be bought through the Texas Windstorm Insurance Association2.
No policy covers age. The Missouri Department of Insurance states that wear and tear of a roof over time is not covered, and that a windstorm that rips up a section of the roof is3. Much of what follows is about how an insurer separates the two.
Wind and hail together are the largest source of homeowners claims. Verisk data published by the Insurance Information Institute puts wind and hail at 2.97 claims per 100 insured homes a year for 2020 to 2024, with an average payment of $15,708 per claim4. Those figures combine wind with hail and exclude Texas.
Replacement cost and actual cash value
A policy states how a loss is valued. The Missouri regulator lists three bases3.
| Basis | What it pays | Effect on a hail-damaged roof |
|---|---|---|
| Replacement cost value (RCV) | The cost to repair or replace the damaged property without deducting for depreciation3 | The cost of the new roof less the deductible5 |
| Actual cash value (ACV) | The depreciated cost to repair or replace the damaged property3 | The cost of the new roof less depreciation for age and less the deductible5 |
| Functional replacement cost | A functional replacement, which is not necessarily of the same quality as the original35 | A tile roof may be replaced with shingles3 |
Two regulators have published worked examples.
The Oklahoma Insurance Department compares neighbors with identical ten-year-old roofs, a $15,000 replacement cost and a $1,000 deductible. The household with replacement cost coverage receives $14,000. The household with actual cash value coverage, with the roof depreciated at $1,000 a year, receives $4,0005.
The Texas Office of Public Insurance Counsel uses a ten-year-old roof that the company says has depreciated 50 percent, a $10,000 replacement and a $2,000 deductible. Under replacement cost the owner pays $2,000 and the company $8,000. Under actual cash value the owner pays $7,000 and the company $3,000, and the difference "is not recoverable"2.
Age matters more than any other variable. The Oklahoma guide notes that for a 20-year-old roof, an actual cash value policy "may pay as little as 20% of the cost to replace the roof, since the useful life of a roof is usually about 25 years"5.
Recoverable depreciation and its deadline
Replacement cost is usually paid in two parts. The insurer first pays the actual cash value. When the policyholder presents evidence that the property has been repaired or replaced, the insurer pays the difference, which is called recoverable depreciation5.
The second payment has a deadline. The Oklahoma guide states that the limit "can range from 6 months to up to one year, depending on your state's laws and your policy", and that after a very large disaster insurers will give more time to a policyholder who asks5. The Nebraska Department of Insurance describes the period as "usually 180 days" and adds that the policy will specify it6.
In Texas the second payment also depends on the deductible. An insurer may refuse to pay withheld recoverable depreciation until it receives reasonable proof that the policyholder paid the deductible, such as a canceled check or a credit card statement7.
Policies that pay the roof by its age
A replacement cost policy does not always extend replacement cost to the roof. The Oklahoma guide warns that "there may be other limits on what the policy will pay for damage to certain surfaces, such as roofs", and that in some cases "the policy may pay ACV on your roof, but RCV on the rest of your home and property"5. Some policies also apply a special deductible to the roof alone, as a flat amount or a percentage5.
Endorsements of this kind are often called roof schedules, because they set the share of the roof's cost that the insurer pays according to its age. The regulators' pages we read describe the effect and do not use one label, and insurers name the endorsement differently. The practical test is the one the Texas Office of Public Insurance Counsel gives shoppers: ask whether any claims under the policy are paid on an actual cash value basis2.
The cosmetic damage exclusion
The Oklahoma Insurance Department lists "exceptions for cosmetic damage, meaning it only affects the aesthetics rather than function of the house" among the limits a policy may place on hail cover1.
Where the exclusion applies, the adjuster's task changes. The question is no longer whether hail marked the roof but whether the mark reduced what the roof does. That is a judgment about function, and it is where an owner and an insurer most often read the same roof differently.
Material choice bears on both halves of the question. The same department advises homeowners to invest in hail-resistant shingles "that are resistant to both cosmetic and functional damage", and notes that many insurers offer discounts for impact-resistant roofing1. Nebraska's regulator notes the same discounts for impact-resistant roofing and siding6.
Like kind and quality
Replacement cost pays for what was there. Most replacement cost policies cover repair with property of "like kind and quality": a roof of 3-tab shingles is replaced with 3-tab shingles and not with slate5. An owner who upgrades pays the difference.
After the claim: premium and renewal
State rules diverge here, and the published guidance covers three of the twelve states in our table.
- Texas. The Consumer Bill of Rights states that an insurer cannot increase a premium based on claims for damage from natural causes, including weather-related damage, and cannot refuse to renew a policy on that basis8.
- Nebraska. The Department of Insurance notes that some companies consider occurrences of wind and hail damage when they review whether to renew, even if no money was paid out6.
- Indiana. The Department of Insurance warns that insurers are allowed to consider claims activity in deciding whether to renew, and that small claims count9.
A plan for the policy you have
- Find three lines on the declarations page: the wind and hail deductible, the valuation basis for the dwelling and any separate basis for the roof5.
- Read the endorsements for the words cosmetic and actual cash value. These are the two terms that reduce a roof payment most12.
- Do the arithmetic before filing. Replacement cost, less depreciation if the roof is on actual cash value, less the deductible. If the result is small or negative, the Nebraska regulator's advice is to consider not filing6.
- Report promptly and hold permanent repairs until the inspection10.
- Keep the repair inside the recoverable depreciation period, and ask for an extension in writing if the work cannot be finished in time5.
- If the insurer questions whether hail fell on the date of loss, add storm evidence for the address to the file. Our guide on what the insurer checks covers the options, including a satellite verification report from Skybridge Intelligence, which the company describes as independent evidence that supports a claim and an adjuster's inspection11.
The result to aim for is a payment the owner could have predicted from the policy before the storm: repair cost, less a known deductible, less a known depreciation if the roof is on actual cash value.
Frequently asked questions
Does homeowners insurance cover hail damage to the roof?
In most standard policies, yes. The Oklahoma Insurance Department states that most standard homeowners insurance covers hail damage to the roof and other parts of the home. The payment is then reduced by the deductible, and may be reduced further if the roof is covered at actual cash value or if the damage is classed as cosmetic and the policy excludes it.
What does actual cash value mean for a roof?
The insurer pays the cost to repair or replace the roof minus depreciation for its age and wear. In the Oklahoma regulator's example a ten-year-old roof that costs $15,000 to replace, depreciated at $1,000 a year with a $1,000 deductible, produces a payment of $4,000. The same loss under replacement cost coverage pays $14,000.
Is cosmetic hail damage covered by insurance?
Only if the policy has no cosmetic damage exclusion. Where the exclusion applies, damage that affects the look of a surface and not its function is not paid. The exclusion is an endorsement, so it appears in the policy documents and can be checked before a storm.
When does the insurer pay the recoverable depreciation?
After the repair. Under replacement cost coverage the insurer may first pay the actual cash value and pay the difference once the policyholder shows that the property has been repaired or replaced. There is a time limit, which the Oklahoma regulator's guide puts at six months to one year depending on state law and the policy, and which the Nebraska regulator describes as usually 180 days.
Will a hail claim raise my homeowners premium?
The rule depends on the state. In Texas the Consumer Bill of Rights states that an insurer cannot increase a premium, or refuse to renew, based on claims for damage from natural causes including weather. Nebraska's and Indiana's regulators both note that insurers may weigh claims history when deciding whether to renew.
Sources
- Wind and hail. Oklahoma Insurance Department. Accessed 20 Nov 2026.
- Residential property: shopping guide. Texas Office of Public Insurance Counsel. Accessed 20 Nov 2026.
- Raising the roof on insurance coverage. Missouri Department of Insurance. Accessed 20 Nov 2026.
- Facts + Statistics: Homeowners and renters insurance. Insurance Information Institute. Accessed 20 Nov 2026.
- Post-Disaster Claims Guide. Oklahoma Insurance Department. Accessed 20 Nov 2026.
- Hail damage: does my roof need repair?. Nebraska Department of Insurance. Accessed 20 Nov 2026.
- Texas Insurance Code, Chapter 707: payment of insurance deductible. Texas Legislature, Texas Constitution and Statutes. Accessed 20 Nov 2026.
- Consumer Bill of Rights: Homeowners, Dwelling, and Renters Insurance (28 TAC §5.9971(b), 2024 version). Texas Department of Insurance, published by the Office of Public Insurance Counsel. Accessed 20 Nov 2026.
- Insurance claim tips. Indiana Department of Insurance. Accessed 20 Nov 2026.
- Director of Insurance offers tips for individuals affected by weather-related damages. Nebraska Department of Insurance. Accessed 20 Nov 2026.
- Skybridge Intelligence: llms.txt (what a report is, data sources, prices, framing). Skybridge Intelligence. Accessed 20 Nov 2026.
Updated 20 Nov 2026: First published.
