Contents
A driver who finds the hood and roof of a car covered in dents wants one fact: whether the policy pays. The answer takes a minute to find, because it rests on a single coverage that is optional and that many owners of older cars have dropped.
Comprehensive is the coverage that pays
Comprehensive coverage, also called "other than collision" coverage1, covers a car against events that are not crashes. The Insurance Information Institute's list reads: "fire, falling objects, missiles, explosion, earthquake, windstorm, hail, flood", along with vandalism and contact with animals, and it includes a cracked or shattered windshield2. Georgia's insurance regulator describes it as paying for damage "from almost all other causes, including fire, severe weather, vandalism, floods and theft"1.
For hail specifically, the Oklahoma Insurance Department states that comprehensive "may help pay to repair auto body, windshield and interior damage caused by hail"3.
The sums are large in aggregate. State Farm reported paying more than $1.2 billion for auto repairs within its 2024 hail claims. The figure is the company's own, as cited by the Insurance Information Institute4.
What the other coverages do
| Coverage | What it pays for | Hail on your own car |
|---|---|---|
| Liability | Damage you cause to others with your vehicle3 | Not covered3 |
| Collision | Damage from a collision with another car or an object, or from flipping over2 | Not the coverage that applies |
| Comprehensive | Fire, theft, vandalism, falling objects, windstorm, hail and flood2 | Covered, less the deductible23 |
Comprehensive is optional coverage1. The regulator's description of the basic package is liability, with collision and comprehensive as additions that the law does not require1. That is how an insured driver ends up with an uninsured hail loss.
The deductible
Comprehensive is usually sold with its own deductible, separate from the collision deductible2. The deductible applies each time a claim is filed5, so two hailstorms in a season mean two deductibles.
The choice of deductible is a trade. Raising an auto deductible from $200 to $500 can reduce the premium for collision and comprehensive coverage, and $1,000 may save more5. A driver in a state with frequent hail is more likely than most to pay that deductible. Texas recorded 902 hail events with stones of one inch or more in 2025, Kansas 375 and Oklahoma 3694.
Unlike a homeowners policy, an auto policy states the deductible as a dollar amount. Percentage deductibles "generally only apply to homeowners policies"5.
What the insurer asks of the owner
The Illinois Department of Insurance sets out the duties that most auto policies place on a policyholder after a loss6.
- Report the loss immediately to the agent or company.
- Protect the vehicle from further damage. The department's example is a broken windshield left uncovered: if rain then ruins the upholstery, the company could refuse to pay for the upholstery.
- Cooperate with the investigation and show the damaged vehicle if asked.
- Submit a proof of loss if the policy requires one. In Illinois, most policies require a sworn proof of loss within 91 days after the loss7.
On the insurer's side, Illinois rules require the company to communicate with the policyholder within 21 working days after it is notified6. The owner is not required to use the repair shop the company suggests, though if the chosen shop charges more the owner may have to pay the difference6.
When hail totals the car
An insurer that judges a car a total loss settles on the car's value and not on the repair estimate. The rules below are Illinois's, as its regulator publishes them. Other states differ.
The settlement is the car's value, not the repair cost. Most policies require the company to pay the vehicle's actual cash value. Companies normally find the retail value in published guide books or computerized sources6.
A loan can exceed the settlement. If the vehicle's value is less than the car loan, the owner must pay the difference6.
Old damage reduces the figure. The insurer may deduct an unlimited amount for old, unrepaired collision damage, and up to $500 for wear and tear, missing parts and rust. Every deduction must be itemized with its dollar amount7.
Taxes and fees. If the owner proves the purchase or lease of another vehicle within 30 days of a cash settlement, the company must pay the applicable sales tax, transfer and title fees7.
Keeping the car. Illinois does not generally allow an owner to keep the salvage after a total loss. One of the two exceptions is a vehicle that "has incurred only hail damage that does not affect the operational safety of the vehicle"7.
If the offer looks low
The first step is to compare the insurer's estimate with the repair shop's, line by line, and make sure both cover the same work8. If the two sides still disagree on the amount, many policies contain an appraisal clause, under which each side hires an appraiser. The owner pays for their own appraiser and a share of the other costs, and the appraisers decide the cost of repair, not what the policy covers8. A complaint to the state insurance department is the other route3.
A plan for the day after the storm
- Check the policy for comprehensive coverage and its deductible. Both are on the declarations page2.
- Photograph the car where it stands, with the hailstones if they have not melted, and note the address and the time.
- Report the claim as soon as possible3.
- Cover broken glass to keep rain out of the interior6.
- Get the repair estimate in writing and compare it with the deductible. A repair that costs less than the deductible produces no payment.
- Keep a record of where the car was parked on the date of loss. The storm that matters is the one over that spot. Where the insurer questions whether hail fell there on that date, a verification report for the location documents what was recorded. Skybridge Intelligence issues one for an address or a point with a radius, for a window of one to three days9. Its sample report states that the indicators it describes do not by themselves prove damage on the ground10, so it supports the inspection of the car and does not replace it.
The outcome to expect with comprehensive coverage is a repair paid less the deductible, or the car's actual cash value if it is a total loss. Before the next season, the Oklahoma regulator's advice is the practical one: put the car in a garage or under cover when hail is forecast, and consider a padded cover if there is no garage3.
Frequently asked questions
Does liability insurance cover hail damage to my car?
No. Liability coverage pays for damage you cause to other people and their property. The Oklahoma Insurance Department states that a driver with only liability coverage may not be covered for a hail damage claim. Hail on your own car is paid under comprehensive coverage.
Is hail damage a comprehensive or a collision claim?
Comprehensive. The Insurance Information Institute lists hail, windstorm, flood and falling objects among the events comprehensive covers, and describes collision as covering damage from a crash with another car or an object.
Can I keep a car that hail has totaled?
It depends on the state. In Illinois the regulator states that an owner generally may not keep the salvage once the insurer has declared a total loss, with an exception for a vehicle that has only hail damage that does not affect its operational safety. Other states set their own rules, so ask the insurer and the state insurance department.
Should I add comprehensive coverage before hail season?
If the car would be costly to repair or replace, yes, and early. The Oklahoma Insurance Department's advice is to buy comprehensive coverage well before you think you will need it.
How long does the insurer have to respond to a car hail claim?
State rules set the period. In Illinois the insurer must communicate with the policyholder within 21 working days after it is notified of the loss. Other states set their own periods, so check your state's rule.
Sources
- Auto insurance. Georgia Office of the Commissioner of Insurance and Safety Fire. Accessed 20 Nov 2026.
- What is covered by a basic auto insurance policy?. Insurance Information Institute. Accessed 20 Nov 2026.
- Wind and hail. Oklahoma Insurance Department. Accessed 20 Nov 2026.
- Facts + Statistics: Hail. Insurance Information Institute. Accessed 20 Nov 2026.
- Understanding your insurance deductibles. Insurance Information Institute. Accessed 20 Nov 2026.
- Filing a claim with your own insurance company. Illinois Department of Insurance. Accessed 20 Nov 2026.
- Total loss auto claims with your insurance company. Illinois Department of Insurance. Accessed 20 Nov 2026.
- Ways to resolve your claim payment disputes. Texas Office of Public Insurance Counsel. Accessed 20 Nov 2026.
- Skybridge Intelligence: llms.txt (what a report is, data sources, prices, framing). Skybridge Intelligence. Accessed 20 Nov 2026.
- A complete sample report: hail and lightning, Kankakee, IL, 10 March 2026. Skybridge Intelligence. Accessed 20 Nov 2026.
Updated 20 Nov 2026: First published.
